Requiem for America

by Daniel R. Snyder

        I am burdened with guilt.  I do not want it, but I cannot dismiss it because as an American, I must accept my share of responsibility for the actions of this country.  From within and from without, I am held accountable.  The dream of our founding fathers was to create “A government of the people, by the people, for the people.”  It was a glorious dream, a magnificent vision: an edifice constructed on the firm foundation of democratic principles.  Now, that foundation is crumbling.
        It is doing so because we are no longer a nation guided by principle, but a nation guided by fear.  We are afraid of threats from without, and we are afraid of threats from within.  Our fear is destroying our international relationships, but equally as important, it is destroying our relationships among ourselves, and it is driving us toward the dismantling of the Constitution. Of course, that the current administration will continue for another four years comes as no surprise, since a majority of our people apparently supports this destruction.    
        On September 11th 2001, we became a frightened nation.  That fear has not left us, and in order to feel safe, we are willing to surrender those freedoms granted to us in the Bill of Rights.  The Fourth Amendment grants us due process, the comfort of knowing that we cannot be held without charge, without bail, and without representation.  We have allowed our government to undermine this amendment by letting it create loopholes that define people as “enemy combatants” and “ghost prisoners.”  This amendment also grants us the freedom from unreasonable search and seizure; our persons, houses, papers, and effects cannot be searched without the issuance of a warrant based on probable cause, and yet The Patriot Act does just the opposite, providing law enforcement with unreasonable freedom to invade our private lives without informing us--to wiretap, to search without warrant, to even monitor what we research in libraries and on the Internet.  Our representatives in the House and the Senate, and even our Chief Executive, turned their backs on this amendment, and we let them do so because we are afraid.  
        We fear that unless we tell people what to do, they will make the wrong choices. The First Amendment also grants us freedom to exercise the religion of our choice, the right to make personal and private decisions based upon our own understanding of the Creator and His wishes.  And yet, for a second term, we will have a president who feels he can legislate based upon his religious convictions.  His arguments against stem cell research and abortion are based on theology.  Although he is entitled to his religious beliefs, the Constitution does not grant him the right to create law based upon them. When life begins--because science cannot answer it-- is a question that can only be answered through our faith.  Thus, whether stem cell research and abortion are “sins” is for God to decide, not our government. Our founding fathers were wise enough to realize that some deeds were answerable to the state, and some were answerable to only the Creator, and thus cannot be legislated.  Our President, and much of our country, has forgotten that because we are afraid.
        We are afraid of hearing dissenting points of view. The First Amendment grants us the right of free speech and the right to peaceably assemble, the right to come together and say, expressing in a manner of our own choosing, “This is what I believe.”  Both of these rights were denied to people across the country at political rallies: New York, Phoenix, Philadelphia, Cincinnati, and the list goes on.  I grant that some were not there to “peaceably assemble,” that their arrests were justified, but that certainly was not the case at Michigan’s Saginaw Valley State University, where Ellen Garrett was arrested for simply wearing a United States Flag outfit in protest of Mr. Bush.  Apparently, her right to free speech only applied if she agreed with the President.  Since we voted for this man a second time, we, like him, are so afraid of dissenting points of view that we are willing to deny people their constitutional rights to keep them quiet.      
        We are afraid of those who are different. The First Amendment guarantees us the right to the pursuit of happiness.  It does not require a huge stretch of the imagination to see that the freedom to marry should fall into this category. And yet, 10 states voted to ratify their constitutions to limit this right; however, a right is not a privilege to be assigned to some and not to others.  It is something to which all people--whether we like or dislike or approve or disapprove of them--are entitled.  State Constitutions should defend rights, ensuring they are fairly and equally distributed. Because we apparently detest and fear homosexuality, we voted to use our constitutions in a manner that stands in direct opposition to their purpose.  And if the president we recently re-elected gets his way, the United States Constitution is probably not far behind.
        Our fear of terrorism drove us to start a war against a country that did not attack us, before all the evidence was in that would establish whether or not it was actually a threat.  And even if evidence turns up that shows a preemptive war was morally justified, that it was worth the cost in human lives, our fear of having to pay for it caused us to reelect a president who promised not to raise our taxes, ensuring that he will continue to drive this country into unprecedented debt, while failing to provide even minimal levels of heath care to a rapidly growing percentage of uninsured people in the very country he is sworn to protect.   
        In our fear, we have handed over the governing of this nation to a hypocrite, a man who professes faith in Jesus while ignoring many of His most fundamental teachings:  For if you forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father also will forgive you; You shall love your neighbor as yourself; Let him who is without sin cast the first stone; Do not judge, or you too will be judged; and Render unto Caesar the things which are Caesar’s, and unto God the things that are God’s.  In our fear, we have handed over the governing of this nation to a man who professes faith in democracy, unless people disagree with him, in which case their views are irrelevant, unpatriotic, or seditious. In our fear, we have handed over the governing of this nation to representatives who legislate based on religion, who create laws that invalidate our rights to privacy and personal choice, who reject the very principles upon which this once great nation was founded.
        We are no longer, “One nation, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.”  We are becoming something else.  For the moment, there are still a few vestiges of greatness left in this country.  We still have the freedom to vote, to influence the future, to shape what it is and what it will become.  But I have to wonder, once we have voted away the last of our freedoms, in this war on terror and this war on ourselves, what will we be trying to protect?
        Shame on every single one of us.  Shame on you for not voting because you do not feel it  makes a difference.  Shame on you for being so afraid that you are willing to sign away our rights in order to feel safe.  Shame on you because you fear more for the size of your bank account than for the value of human health, life, and dignity.  Shame on you for giving our leaders the power to legislate based upon your fears and prejudices.  And mostly, shame on me for not doing more to stop you.

Originally Published in Blue Ear
© 2004 by Daniel R. Snyder


Daniel R. SnyderThanks for Visiting!
                      Return to Daniel R. Snyder's Homepage
                                                 Contact: drsnyder1@charter.net